Comparison
Astra Superior Platinum vs other double edge blades
How reviewers describe it next to Derby, Feather, Shark and others.
We do not run lab tests. This page collects what published reviewers and forum members say, with a link for each point, so you can read the originals. The brands named are other blade makers, not shops.
| Comparison | What reviewers say | Source |
|---|---|---|
| Astra vs Feather | “These might not be as sharp as a Feather or as smooth as a Shark or Derby, but they are well above average in both categories.” | A Superior Shave |
| Astra vs Astra Superior Stainless (blue pack) | “Try the Astras’ brother, the Astra Superior Stainless in the blue pack… sharper than the SP and still smooth.” (Alum Ladd) | Badger & Blade thread |
| Astra vs Gillette Platinum | Gillette Platinums “are also consistent and are sharper than the Astras.” (u/MrArmageddon12) | r/wicked_edge |
| Where to start | “Try the Derby & Astras first… I’d leave the Feather & Sharks (sharper) until you’ve worked on your technique for a while.” (u/Mo_Jack) | r/wicked_edge |
Who it suits
- Beginners and anyone wanting a mild, forgiving, consistent blade.
- Daily shavers who like a low cost per blade.
- Anyone who wants a baseline to measure other blades against.
Who may want something sharper
Opinions on coarse hair are genuinely split, so here are both sides:
“I have coarse hair and the Astra’s work great for me. Very smooth and really mows it down.”
u/spyresca (4 Sep 2025) · r/wicked_edge
“Above average blades but not not for me. Medium/low sharpness.”
u/Interesting_Tea5715, who has thick, coarse hair (4 Sep 2025) · r/wicked_edge
Experience varies with razor, prep and beard type. Quoted verbatim and linked to the source thread.
Try one, keep notes, then decide.
Video comparisons
Channel: Friendship Shaving · Watch on YouTube
Channel: The Canuck Shaver · Watch on YouTube
Independent channels; the opinions are theirs. Videos load in privacy-enhanced mode.
Sources
- r/wicked_edge: Where to start with my beginner blades? (Sep 2024)
- r/wicked_edge: Advice – which blades do you guys recommend I start with? (Mar 2025)
- r/wicked_edge: Can someone explain the differences? (Jan 2024)
- r/wicked_edge: Review: Astra Superior Platinum (Sep 2025)
- Badger & Blade: Astra Superior Platinum member reviews
- Badger & Blade: Tell me a blade better than the Astra
- A Superior Shave: Astra Superior Platinum review
- YouTube – Friendship Shaving: The Astra Green (Superior Platinum) Razor Blade Review
- YouTube – The Canuck Shaver: How to Wet Shave, a beginners guide
Read in November 2026. Third-party pages may change.